Custom Orders

"Can you create this?" the mom asked sheepishly, as she pulled out a drawing of a robo-dino-tiger monster her 7 year old son had created.
Sure enough, the birthday cake was a smash hit.

At Tribeca Treats we really enjoy creating and decorating treats that are just right for your occasion. From weddings to first birthdays to going-away parties, our cakes, cupcakes, cookies and chocolates have popped up at events all over the New York City area and around the country.

Visit our Gallery to view a small selection of our custom creations, or stop in to our store to see our look-book with more designs.  For even more photos, follow us or visit us on Instagram.

Because all of our custom treats are baked fresh to order, we do need a little lead time to make sure they are baked and/or decorated to your liking. We created this guideline to give you an idea of different options available, depending on how soon you need to pick up your treats. 

We cannot guarantee availability, however, as we do occasionally get booked to capacity, so we recommend ordering as soon as possible.  Likewise, we can *sometimes* accomodate orders with less notice, so don't be afraid to ask.

Help! I need something today (or within about 24 hours)!

  • Cupcakes in quantities up to 60 based on our daily selection of flavors (ask about our decorative toppers, if you want to spell out a message)
  • Gift baskets with assorted cookies, brownies, chocolates, cupcakes, etc. in a wide range of price points
  • Most of our daily selection of treats in quantities up to about 24 (see Our Treats for a menu)

I've been swamped at work and am just getting to this now... (about 48 hours notice)

  • 6", 8", or 9" cakes in standard chocolate or vanilla combinations or red velvet (undecorated or with multi-colored polka dots); some specialty flavors may be available--please inquire
  • Cupcakes in any quantity based on our daily selection of flavors
  • Custom sugar cookies in a variety of shapes decorated with sprinkles
  • Anything in the above category

We just finalized our plans this week. (3 days to a week notice)

  • Cakes in any of our standard round sizes, sheet cakes, two tiered cakes; typically all flavors are available, except seasonal flavors (see cake menu); wide range of 2-dimensional decorations available, customized for your preference
  • Anything in the above categories

I am SO on-the-ball. (more than one week notice)

  • More elaborate or multi-tiered cakes; cakes with 3-dimensional decorations
  • Custom frosted cookies in a wide range of shapes, decorated with royal icing
  • Customized truffles (ie, specific flavors, monograms, etc.)
  • Anything from the above categories

For wedding and other large event cakes:

For large, multi-tiered, decorated cakes, please contact us 3-12 weeks from your event. We will initially discuss your design ideas and the details for your event, then we will follow up with 2-3 price quotes based on that discussion. Once you have signed a contract, you can come in for a tasting and final design sign-off (about 10 days to 4 weeks from your event.)

Facebook and Twitter